
Elizabethtown, New Mexico, often referred to as “E-Town,” is a ghost town in Colfax County, located along the Enchanted Circle Scenic Byway between Eagle Nest and Red River. Founded in 1866, it was the first incorporated town in New Mexico and briefly served as the Colfax County seat. This report explores the town’s origins, its rapid rise during the gold rush, its decline, and its lasting legacy as a historical site.
Origins and Establishment (1866–1868)
Elizabethtown’s history began in 1866, a year after the American Civil War, when a Ute Indian, grateful for Captain William H. Moore’s earlier kindness, presented him with copper ore samples at Fort Union, northeast of Las Vegas, New Mexico. Recognizing the value of the ore, Moore led a scouting party to Baldy Mountain, where they discovered not only copper but also gold in Willow Creek. Despite Lucien Maxwell’s ownership of the land, the news of gold spread, attracting thousands of prospectors by 1867. Maxwell, unable to stop the influx, charged usage fees and built toll roads to capitalize on the boom.
In 1867, Captain Moore, his brother, and other businessmen platted a townsite, naming it Elizabethtown after Moore’s four-year-old daughter, Elizabeth Catherine Moore. The town was surveyed with wide streets and distinct residential and commercial zones, and lots were sold for $800 to $1,200. By March 1868, Elizabethtown had 100 buildings, including John Moore’s general store, five stores, seven saloons, two hotels, three dance halls, and a drugstore. It became New Mexico’s first incorporated town in 1869 and the first seat of the newly formed Colfax County.
The Gold Rush Boom (1868–1870)
The discovery of gold in every creek and gulch around Baldy Mountain fueled a frenzy of mining activity. By 1869, an estimated 5,000 to 9,000 people lived in Elizabethtown, making it New Mexico’s most populous place at the time. The Moreno Valley became a hub for placer mining, with miners using dry-washing jigs, sluices, and gold pans along Moreno Hill, Ute Mountain, and Ponil Creek. Hard rock mines, such as the Mystic Copper Mine and the Aztec Mine (later part of the Philmont Boy Scout Ranch), also thrived. The Aztec Mine, managed by Prussian-born Lt. Colonel Edward Bergmann, produced roughly $1.5 million in gold in its first five years.
The town’s rapid growth brought prosperity and a vibrant, if rowdy, social scene. Saloons, gambling halls, and a red-light district flourished, with “ladies of the night” operating in cabins and second-floor saloon rooms. The newspaper The Lantern began publication in 1869, and a stage line offered daily service to Cimarron, Taos, and Santa Fe. However, the harsh winters and limited water supply posed challenges. The Moreno Water and Mining Company addressed the latter by constructing the Big Ditch in 1868 to divert water from the Red River, enabling more efficient placer mining.
Elizabethtown also gained notoriety for its lawlessness. Vigilante justice was common, with figures like Clay Allison, a former Confederate officer and rancher, leading mob actions. One infamous incident involved Charles Kennedy, a serial killer who lured travelers to his rest stop between Elizabethtown and Taos, killing up to 14 people. In 1870, after his wife exposed his crimes, an enraged mob led by Allison dragged Kennedy through the streets and lynched him.
Decline and Brief Revival (1871–1903)
By 1871, the easily accessible gold deposits were depleted, and mining costs began to outweigh profits. The population plummeted to about 100 residents by 1872, and the county seat was moved to Cimarron. Elizabethtown was nearly a ghost town by 1875. A brief revival occurred in 1878 when the Atchison, Topeka, and Santa Fe Railroad extended tracks from Trinidad, Colorado, into New Mexico, making mining feasible again. Schools opened, and social events like Gold Rush Days attracted visitors. In 1901, the Oro Dredging Company’s Eleanor dredge processed 4,000 cubic yards of dirt daily, producing a quarter of New Mexico’s gold that year.
Despite these efforts, a devastating fire in September 1903, starting in Remsberg’s store, destroyed most of the town, including the Mutz Hotel and much of the commercial district. Only Froelick’s general store survived. The fire was a fatal blow, and by 1917, with mining operations ceasing, Elizabethtown was officially a ghost town. The post office, established in 1868, closed in 1931.
Legacy and Modern Elizabethtown
Today, Elizabethtown is a quiet historical site with few remnants: the ruins of the Mutz Hotel, Froelick’s store (in poor repair), a rebuilt church, and scattered stone walls. The Elizabethtown Museum, housed in a former schoolteacher’s home, displays artifacts, photos, and documents, offering insights into the town’s mining past. The cemetery, a mile up the road, contains graves like that of Florence May Myrick (1880–1889), reflecting the town’s personal stories. The site, partly owned by Mutz family descendants, is accessible via New Mexico State Road 38 and attracts tourists, historians, and ghost town enthusiasts. ATV and horseback tours are available, and the museum operates seasonally.
Elizabethtown’s history is also tied to broader regional events, such as the Colfax County War (1870s), a land dispute involving vigilantes and the Santa Fe Ring, a corrupt territorial government. Notorious figures like Tom “Black Jack” Ketchum and his Hole-in-the-Wall Gang frequented the town, adding to its Wild West reputation. Despite its brief prominence, Elizabethtown produced over 100,000 ounces of gold, a significant achievement for a New Mexican mining district.
Conclusion
Elizabethtown, New Mexico, exemplifies the boom-and-bust cycle of American mining towns. From its founding in 1866 amid a gold rush to its decline by 1917, the town experienced rapid growth, lawlessness, and resilience before succumbing to fire and economic collapse. Its sparse ruins and museum preserve the memory of a once-thriving community that shaped New Mexico’s early history. Elizabethtown remains a poignant reminder of the challenges and dreams that defined the American West.
Sources
- Legends of America: Elizabethtown, New Mexico – Gone But Not Forgotten
- New Mexico True: Elizabethtown New Mexico Ghost Town
- New Mexico Nomad: New Mexico Ghost Towns: Elizabethtown
- FamilySearch: The Elizabethtown Story, Colfax County, New Mexico
- Nomadic Niko: Elizabethtown (Ghost Town in New Mexico)
- FamilySearch: Elizabethtown, Colfax County, New Mexico, Cemetery Details
- Gold Rush Nuggets: Mining History of Elizabethtown, New Mexico









