Early Life and Beginnings
Thomas Long Smith, known as “Peg Leg” Smith, was born on October 10, 1801, in Crab Orchard, Kentucky. As a teenager, he left home seeking adventure, finding work on a flatboat navigating the Mississippi River. By the time he reached St. Louis, Missouri, Smith joined the ranks of fur trappers employed by John Jacob Astor, working alongside legendary mountain men like Kit Carson, Jim Bridger, and Milton Sublette. His early years were marked by a restless spirit and a knack for survival in the rugged American frontier.
Adventures as a Mountain Man
In the 1820s, Smith established himself as a skilled trapper and scout, joining expeditions that explored the American Southwest, including present-day New Mexico. He accompanied Alexandre Le Grand’s expedition as a scout, learning several Native American languages and adapting to the harsh environments of the frontier. His ability to navigate and communicate with Indigenous peoples made him a valuable guide for early expeditions.
In 1827, during a trapping expedition in North Park, Colorado, Smith’s life took a dramatic turn. Wounded in the left leg during a skirmish with local Indigenous people, he faced a dire situation. With no medical help available, Smith, assisted by fellow trapper Milton Sublette and fortified by a jug of “Taos Lightning” (a potent whiskey), amputated his own leg below the knee. Sublette sawed through the bone, and the wound was cauterized with a heated rifle barrel. Taken in by Ute women who treated his wound with traditional remedies, Smith recovered and crafted a wooden leg, earning the nickname “Peg Leg.” He adapted remarkably, learning to ride horses and even using his detachable wooden leg as a weapon in barroom brawls, cementing his reputation as a fierce and resourceful frontiersman.
A Life of Diverse Ventures
Smith’s career as a fur trapper thrived despite his disability, but by the 1840s, the decline of the fur trade pushed him toward less savory pursuits. He turned to horse theft, targeting large Mexican haciendas in California. In 1839, alongside mountain man Jim Beckwourth and Ute chief Walkara, Smith orchestrated a massive theft, rustling 3,000 horses from California ranches and driving them to New Mexico for profit. His partnership with Walkara also involved guiding 150 Utes across the Sierra Nevada, stealing hundreds of horses in daring raids. These exploits, while lucrative, drew the ire of authorities, forcing Smith to abandon horse thieving by the late 1840s.
During the late 1840s, Smith operated a trading post along the Oregon Trail near the Idaho-Wyoming border, assisting emigrants with supplies and repairs. Travelers described him as a “jolly one-legged man,” a testament to his charisma and resilience. He also engaged in prospecting, particularly in the Borrego Badlands of southeastern California, where his most enduring legend was born.
The Legend of the Lost Peg Leg Mine
Smith’s greatest claim to fame—and controversy—revolves around the so-called Lost Peg Leg Mine. According to legend, in 1829, while traveling from Yuma to Los Angeles, Smith attempted a desert shortcut and lost his way. Climbing a hill to regain his bearings, he noticed black, burned-looking rocks sprinkled with yellow particles. He collected samples, later learning in Los Angeles that these were gold nuggets. Despite repeated attempts, Smith could never relocate the hill, and the tale of his “lost mine” grew into a frontier myth. He sold maps and claims to the mine until his death, capitalizing on the 1849 California Gold Rush fever, though many doubted his story due to his reputation for embellishment and drinking.
Historical accounts cast doubt on the mine’s existence. Research by the Legend Detectives, a historical team, suggests that the gold mine story may belong to another “Pegleg,” possibly John Smith, active after Thomas Smith’s death. Interviews with Smith’s contemporaries, including trapping partner George Yount, and Smith’s own statements late in life, indicate he never claimed to have found gold. Nonetheless, the legend persists, fueling treasure hunts and the annual Pegleg Smith Liars Contest in Borrego Springs, where storytellers compete in his honor.
Later Years and Legacy
By the 1860s, Smith’s health and fortunes declined. He spent his final years in a veterans’ home in San Francisco, where he died penniless in October 1866 at a hospital, likely at Yerba Buena Cemetery. Conflicting reports, such as a 1930 newspaper claiming he died in a Los Angeles bar fight in 1880, reflect the muddled lore surrounding his life.
Smith’s legacy endures through cultural touchstones. The Peg Leg Smith Monument, established in 1948 by artist Harry Oliver in Anza-Borrego Desert State Park, invites visitors to add ten rocks to a pile for luck in finding the lost mine. Designated California Historical Landmark No. 750 in 1960, the site remains a draw for adventurers and history buffs. Smith appears in historical novels like Louis L’Amour’s The Lonesome Gods and Robert Lewis Taylor’s A Roaring in the Wind, as well as the 1995 game Oregon Trail II, where he runs a trading post. The annual Liars Contest, now held at American Legion Post 853, celebrates his storytelling prowess.
Historical Significance
Peg Leg Smith embodies the contradictions of the American frontier: a trailblazer who helped map the Southwest, a survivor who overcame immense hardship, and a rogue whose questionable deeds fueled his legend. While the Lost Peg Leg Mine may be more myth than reality, Smith’s life as a mountain man, trapper, and larger-than-life character captures the untamed spirit of the Wild West. His story, blending fact and fiction, continues to captivate, reminding us of the era’s rugged individualism and the allure of the unknown.
Pingback: Peg Legs Lost Gold - Destination4x4